Happy Valentine’s Day. (I’m posting this a day early, to avoid the barrage of other posts on this topic tomorrow!)
Please don’t think me a spoil sport or a grump, but I’m not a huge fan of this commercialised day! Hence why I picked the most awful photo for this post that I could find :-)
No it’s not because I’m not married and want to stop those who are in love from celebrating that! It’s a bigger, deeper question and one that I hope we can look at as Christians for whom love is our ultimate goal.
Feb 14th with all its trimmings has become a staple part of the liturgy of our society, so it’s something worth us discussing it and making sure we participate in it with thought.
Photos like the one above are synonymous with Valentines Day – a fluffy hamster and a red heart shaped cushion. Yikes! When I googled the words, these kind of images flooded my screen. Awww, how cute? But not really… all we are doing is elevating an odd perspective on one kind of love and making that the focus of February 14th.
I’m a huge fan of romance and falling in love, don’t get me wrong! But these red heart shaped cushions, fluffy hamsters or cute puppies and the commericalised version of Valentine’s Day, paint a very warped picture of what love really is.
One of my favourite books is C. S. Lewis’ “The Four Loves”. He speaks of the four different kinds of love; Storge (affection/fondness between family or acquaintances), Phileo (friendship), Eros (intimate/romantic) and Agape (the love of God).
These four loves are all beautiful expressions of who we are as humans created in the imago dei- all important and valuable. So it bugs me a bit when a day like February 14th elevates eros to a god-like status and makes all those who don’t have a ring on their finger feel like they are in the 2nd class club or are missing out on what is presented as ‘the most important’ part of life and love!
More than that, Valentines Day perpetuating the images of puppies and hearts and fairy tale romance, doesn’t even do justice to eros. So not only is our sex obsessed culture implying that eros trumps the other 3 loves, even the one love we are celebrating is done so in a warped and lacking manner.
Eros isn’t primarily about fairy tale castles and cute puppies! That promotes an odd version of romance that I see in many of my single female friends. They genuinely think their soul mate is going to ride in on a white horse, rescue them from all their questions, fears and problems and hand them a perfect life on a plate! No wonder they are still single ;-) And no wonder, very sadly, why so many marriages built on these expectations crumble at the first few hurdles.
True eros is much more about the beautiful choice to love through tough times when it feels like all hell breaks loose; to stay faithful even when everything around you lures you away; to sacrifice; to lay down your life for someone else; shared responsibility; late nights washing dishes; early mornings doing school runs or food shopping; working late to save money to pay the bills together; caring for your partner when they are sick; forgoing your wants in favour of what they need. Thats what true eros looks like.
The puppies, cushions and sickly sweetness of Feb 14th perpetuate something a million miles away from the gritty reality of the true commitment needed for a lifelong relationship – and buying into that kind of romance can make people slow to embrace the harder realities of love when they do come along, as the fairytale bubble bursts and the idealised dreams shatter. And the divorce rate rises and rises….
St Valentine (although we don’t know much about him) was a Christian marytr. The first portrait of him is found in the Nuremburg Chronicle of 1493. It describes him helping Christians during the persecution under Claudius II. Valentine would perform marriages for Christians, which was totally forbidden. He generally worked to protect and help followers of Christ. He was arrested for this and killed with clubs and stones, then beheaded.
So we are celebrating a day that remembers a brave follower of Jesus, who stood up for love and truth and gave his life for the gospel. It seems that this saint represents far more than just red heart shaped cushions, puppies, and an idolisation of romantic love?!
What about the love he had for God – so strong that it led him to give his life? What about his love for the Church, shown by his utter commitment to the Christians he helped, protected and acted as Priest to? All these kinds of love are represented in his life and death, so why do we only cling to one – eros – rather than all the others? And an odd version of eros at that!
Valentine comes from the term ‘valens’ meaning ‘worthy, strong, powerful‘. So that should steer us away from equating Feb 14th with a namby pamby, fluffy kind of love. Yes falling in love can feel like floating on a fluffy cloud. But we should also make sure our portrayal of it on Fe 14th also communicates the “valens” strong, gritty, committed form of eros too.
I wish Feb 14th could be a celebration of all four of the loves – a reminder that we are all equally valued, regardless of whether we have a ring on our finger and a ‘special someone’ on our arm, or not. A reminder that all 4 loves are amazing, exhilarating and worthy of being spotlighted.
Lets make this Valentines Day one where we remember to celebrate all four expressions of love. And one where we make sure we don’t idolise or distort the value or eros, or make the single people in society feel left out :-)
Yes, of course, celebrate your boyfriend, girlfriend, husband, wife, partner! Even buy them a card with a fluffy hamster and a heart shaped cushion on it if you really must…! But also reach out to those around you and celebrate friends, church community, family, and above all our love for God.
Let’s make it a true day of love for all, not just for a select few. And a day that honours ALL kinds of love, not just a selective portrayal of just one type.
Over you you:
- What are your thoughts on this? I’d love to know, so comment below!
- You can share this post with others by clicking on the Twitter or Facebook buttons below. I’d love it if you would :)
No related posts.


Pingback: Happy Valentine’s Day! « Connected
Pingback: The value of affection | scottjallen.com
Pingback: All Things Krabbe » Irony, Parenting, and Other Synonyms